Start Submission Become a Reviewer

Reading: Daisyworld revisited: quantifying biological effects on planetary self-regulation

Download

A- A+
Alt. Display

Original Research Papers

Daisyworld revisited: quantifying biological effects on planetary self-regulation

Authors:

Timothy M. Lenton ,

Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Edinburgh Research Station, GB
X close

James E. Lovelock

Coombe Mill, St. Giles on the Heath, GB
X close

Abstract

Daisyworld demonstrates that self-regulation of the global environment can emerge from organisms altering their local environment in different ways. In Daisyworld, natural selection is directly linked to environmental effects such that what is selected for at the individual level is beneficial to the global environment. The model has been modified and extended in many studies that have highlighted the effect of biological processes on system self-regulation. Here we better quantify their effects and present new variants of the model in an attempt to resolve outstanding debates. The results confirm that Daisyworld is a remarkably robust self-regulating system and they offer some general lessons about systems where life has a strong effect on the environment, which we think are relevant to the Earth. As forcing becomes extreme, such systems can exhibit co-existing stable states with and without life (bi-stability), and rapid transitions from one to the other that are difficult to reverse. The growth response of organisms to the environment has a role in determining the range of forcing over which a system can regulate. Density-dependent ecological interactions improve Daisyworld’s regulatory properties, although increased inter-species competition destabilises the environment in one interval. Self-regulation is little affected by introducing organisms that ‘cheat’ by not altering their local environment and in so doing gain a growth advantage. Increased variation in an environment-altering trait (albedo) can weaken the negative feedback it provides on the environment. However, random mutation of this trait and subsequent natural selection can generate and extend the range of temperature regulation and improve the system’s response to perturbation with time. Internal adaptation of organisms toward prevailing environmental conditions, or to tolerate extremes, can also extend the range of forcing over which life persists.

How to Cite: Lenton, T.M. and Lovelock, J.E., 2001. Daisyworld revisited: quantifying biological effects on planetary self-regulation. Tellus B: Chemical and Physical Meteorology, 53(3), pp.288–305. DOI: http://doi.org/10.3402/tellusb.v53i3.16597
5
Views
4
Downloads
  Published on 01 Jan 2001
 Accepted on 15 Dec 2000            Submitted on 7 Mar 2000

REFERENCES

  1. Begon , M. , Harper , J. L. and Townsend , C. R . 1996 . Ecology - individuals, populations and communities . Blackwell , Oxford .  

  2. Betts , R. A . 1999 . Self-beneficial effects of vegetation on climate in an ocean-atmosphere general circulation model . Geophys. Res. Lett . 26 , 1457 – 1460 .  

  3. Carter , R. N. and Prince , S. D . 1981 . Epidemic models used to explain biogeographical distribution limits . Nature 293 , 644 – 645 .  

  4. Claussen , M. , Brovkin , V. , Ganopolski , A. , Kubatzki , C. and Petoukhov , V . 1998 . Modelling global terrestrial vegetation-climate interactions . Philosophical Trans-actions of the Royal Society: Biological Sciences 353 , 53 – 63 .  

  5. Cohen , J. E. and Rich , A. D . 2000 . Interspecific competi-tion affects biological homeostasis in Daisyworld . Tellus 52B , 980 – 984 .  

  6. Dawkins , R . 1983 . The extended phenotype . Oxford University Press , Oxford .  

  7. Doolittle , W. F . 1981 . Is nature really motherly? The CoEvolution Quarterly (Spring), 58 – 63 .  

  8. Hambler , C . 1997 . The new Gaia . British Ecological Society Bulletin 28 , 101 – 104 .  

  9. Harding , S. P . 1999 . Food web complexity enhances community stability and climate regulation in a geo-physiological model . Tellus 51B , 815 – 829 .  

  10. Harding , S. P. and Lovelock , J. E . 1996 . Exploiter-mediated coexistence and frequency-dependent selec-tion in a numerical model of biodiversity . J. Theor-etical Biology 182 , 109 – 116 .  

  11. Keeling , R . 1991 . Mechanisms for stabilization and destabilization of a simple biosphere: catastrophe on Daisyworld . In: Scientists on Gaia (eds. S. H. Schneider and P. J. Boston ). The MIT Press , London , 118 – 120 .  

  12. Koeslag , J. H. , Saunders , P. T. and Wessels , J. A . 1997 . Glucose homeostasis with infinite gain: further lessons from the Daisyworld parable? J. Endocrinol . 154 , 187 – 192 .  

  13. Lashof , D. A . 1991 . Gaia on the brink: biogeochemical feedback processes in global warming . In: Scientists on Gaia (eds. S. H. Schneider and P. J. Boston ). The MIT Press , London , 393 – 404 .  

  14. Lenton , T. M . 1998 . Gaia and natural selection . Nature 394 , 439 – 447 .  

  15. Lenton , T. M. and Betts , R. A . 1998 . From Daisyworld to GCMs: using models to understand the regulation of climate. In: ERCA, vol. 3 , from urban air pollution to extra-solar planets (ed. C. Boutron . EDP Sciences, Les Ulis, France, 145 – 167 .  

  16. Lenton , T. M. and Lovelock , J. E . 2000 . Daisyworld is Darwinian: constraints on adaptation are important for planetary self-regulation . J. Theoretical Biology 206 , 109 – 114 .  

  17. Lovelock , J. E . 1983a . Gaia as seen through the atmo-sphere . In: Biomineralization and biological metal accumulation (eds. P. Westbroek and E. W. d. Jong ) . D. Reidel Publishing Company , Dordrecht , 15 – 25 .  

  18. Lovelock , J. E . 1983b . Daisy World - a cybernetic proof of the Gaia hypothesis. The Co-evolution Quarterly (Summer), 66 – 72 .  

  19. Lovelock , J. E . 1986 . Geophysiology: a new look at earth science . Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 67 , 392 – 397 .  

  20. Lovelock , J. E . 1988 . The ages of Gaia - a biography of our living earth . Oxford University Press , Oxford .  

  21. Lovelock , J. E . 1989 . Geophysiology . Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Sciences 80 , 169 – 175 .  

  22. Lovelock , J. E . 1992 . A numerical model for biodiversity . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London: Biological Sciences 338 , 383 – 391 .  

  23. Lovelock , J. E. and Kump , L. R . 1994 . Failure of climate regulation in a geophysiological model . Nature 369 , 732 – 734 .  

  24. Nevison , C. , Gupta , V. and Klinger , L . 1999 . Self-sustained temperature oscillations on Daisyworld . Tellus 51B , 806 – 814 .  

  25. Pimm , S. L . 1984 . The complexity and stability of eco-systems . Nature 307 , 321 – 326 .  

  26. Raup , D. M. and Sepkoski , J. J . 1986 . Periodic extinction of families and genera . Science 231 , 833 – 836 .  

  27. Robertson , D. and Robinson , J. 1998. Darwinian Daisyworld. J. Theoretical Biology 195 , 129 – 134 .  

  28. Sardeshmukh , P. D . 2000 . Coupled systems with super-negative feedbacks . Geophys. Res. Abstracts 2 , 421 .  

  29. Saunders , P. T . 1994 . Evolution without natural selec-tion: further implications of the Daisyworld parable . J. Theoretical Biology 166 , 365 – 373 .  

  30. Schwartzman , D. W. and Volk , T . 1989 . Biotic enhance-ment of weathering and the habitability of Earth . Nature 340 , 457 – 460 .  

  31. Schwartzman , D. W. and Volk , T . 1991 . Biotic enhance-ment of weathering and surface temperatures on Earth since the origin of life . Palaeogeography, Palaeoclima-tology, Palaeoecology (Global and Planetary Change Section) 90 , 357 – 371 .  

  32. Stocker , S . 1995 . Regarding mutations in Daisyworld models . J. Theoretical Biology 175 , 495 – 501 .  

  33. Von Bloh , W. , Block , A. and Schellnhuber , H. J . 1997 . Self-stabilization of the biosphere under global change: a tutorial geophysiological approach . Tellus 49B , 249 – 262 .  

  34. Von Bloh , W. , Block , A. , Parade , M. and Schellnhuber , H. J . 1999 . Tutorial modelling of geosphere-biosphere interactions: the effect of percolation-type habitat frag-mentation . Physica A 266 , 186 – 196 .  

  35. Watson , A. J. and Lovelock , J. E . 1983 . Biological homeostasis of the global environment: the parable of Daisyworld . Tellus 35B , 284 – 289 .  

  36. Weber , S. L . 2001 . On homeostasis in Daisyworld . Climatic Change 48 , 465 – 485 .  

comments powered by Disqus